Remembering Atlanta's Lost Gay Bars: From Piedmont to History

Atlanta's LGBTQ+ scene has always been vibrant, a tapestry woven with threads of joy, resilience, and a fierce determination to celebrate identity. While iconic establishments like the Atlanta Eagle and Blake's On The Park continue to thrive, it's important to remember the spaces that paved the way - the gay bars that once dotted Piedmont Avenue and beyond, each holding a unique place in the city's queer history.

What stories do these forgotten spaces tell, and how did they shape the community we know today?

The Golden Age and the Shadows of Prejudice

The era following gay liberation saw an explosion of gay bars in Atlanta. These weren't just places to grab a drink; they were cultural hubs.

Many featured elaborate entertainment, employing choreographers, seamstresses, and costume designers to create spectacular productions. But even during this flourishing period, the shadow of discrimination loomed large.

Reports of discriminatory carding policies at some establishments, with African Americans facing stricter ID requirements than their white counterparts, exposed a painful truth: segregation existed even within the gay community.

This led to the rise of distinct "white bars" and "black bars," reflecting the racial divides of the time. How could a community fighting for its own acceptance grapple with its internal biases?

The Tragedy at Otherside Lounge

One bar, Otherside Lounge, located on Piedmont Avenue, suffered a devastating blow on February 21, 1997, when a bomb exploded, injuring five people.

The perpetrator was later identified as Eric Rudolph, a domestic terrorist. While the bar bravely reopened, it never fully recovered and ultimately closed its doors two years later. The bombing served as a stark reminder of the hatred and violence the LGBTQ+ community faced, a chilling event that terrorized the "gay city," as some remember it.

Could a community truly feel safe when targeted by such hate?

Entrapment and Mistrust: The Community and the Police

Adding to the challenges, a deep-seated mistrust existed between the gay community and the Atlanta police. Many claimed to be victims of police entrapment, and felt that officers were slow to respond to calls from gay crime victims.

A Cruise magazine edition even highlighted perceived abuses.

The city eventually agreed to provide better training for its police officers as part of a settlement, but compliance was reportedly slow. This strained relationship further complicated the already difficult path to acceptance and equality. How can a community thrive when it feels alienated from those sworn to protect it?

The Evolution of the Scene: Remembering Rebar and The New Order

In more recent times, the space formerly occupied by otherside lounge was replaced by another gay bar, Rebar, which also eventually shuttered.

The ever-changing landscape reflects the evolving needs and desires of the LGBTQ+ community. One bar that has persevered, albeit in a modified form, is The New Order. Once a sprawling establishment accessible from within a mall, it now occupies what was formerly a separate back section.

What accounts for the longevity of some bars, while others fade away?

The Enduring Appeal of a "Heaven's Waiting Room"

Described affectionately as "Heaven's waiting room" by some, The New Order caters to an older clientele. Patrons appreciate the friendly atmosphere, strong drinks, and the opportunity to connect with others, reminiscing about old times and enjoying the present.

With its diverse age range and accepting atmosphere, bars like The New Order provide a sense of belonging and acceptance. What's the secret ingredient that makes these establishments so inviting to their loyal customers?

While some may poke fun at the more mature crowd, the truth is these spaces provide invaluable connections for older gay men, a demographic often overlooked.

In a world that often glorifies youth, these bars offer a haven of acceptance and camaraderie. As one reviewer aptly put it, "Remember, one day we will ALL be that older man looking for acceptance and a place we can call home."

More Than Just a Bar: A Community Hub

Bars like The New Order are more than just places to drink; they're community hubs.

Patrons can relax, chat with strangers, play pool, or simply unwind while watching a movie. The absence of overt sexual tension, a refreshing contrast to many other establishments, allows for genuine connection and conversation. The bartenders are friendly, the drinks are strong, and the atmosphere is welcoming.

What lessons can be learned from these enduring spaces?

The Legacy Continues

The gay bar scene in Atlanta continues to evolve. While some beloved establishments have closed their doors, new ones emerge, reflecting the changing tastes and needs of the community.

From the infamous Backstreet to the newer spots popping up, the spirit of inclusivity, celebration, and resistance lives on. These spaces remain vital for fostering connection, building community, and honoring the rich history of Atlanta's LGBTQ+ population. What will the next chapter in Atlanta's queer bar history look like, and how will it continue to shape the city's cultural landscape?